False Allegations and the Plight of Innocent Men in India
India has established numerous laws and institutions to ensure women's safety and rights, which are undoubtedly essential. However, in some cases, these laws have been misused to falsely implicate innocent men, severely affecting their lives. The case of Atul Subhash serves as a significant example in this regard.
Atul Subhash Case: A Tragedy of Legal Misuse
Atul Subhash, an IT engineer from Samastipur, Bihar, working in Bengaluru, committed suicide due to legal harassment arising from marital disputes. His wife, Nikita Singhania, filed three cases against him and his family in Jaunpur, including allegations of dowry harassment, domestic violence, and maintenance claims. As a result, Atul had to travel frequently from Bengaluru to Jaunpur, leading to severe mental stress. (Source: Aaj Tak)
Before his suicide, Atul left behind a 24-page suicide note and an 81-minute video, detailing his suffering. He wrote:
"The courts, the police, and the entire system, funded by my own tax money, will continue to harass me, my family, and others like me. If I am no longer here, there will be no money, no reason to harass my parents and brother."
Vishnu Tiwari Case: The Flaws of the Justice System
Atul Subhash’s case brings to light another shocking example—the story of Vishnu Tiwari, a man from Lalitpur who spent 20 years in prison under false rape and SC/ST Act charges. Eventually, he was acquitted by the High Court due to a lack of evidence, but by then, his life was ruined.
During his time in jail, he lost his parents and two brothers, and his family property was sold off. (Source: Navbharat Times)
The Need for a Men's Commission (Purush Aayog)
Despite having numerous laws and institutions like the National Commission for Women (NCW) and various women-centric laws, there is no dedicated Men’s Commission (Purush Aayog) in India. Many activists and legal experts have demanded the formation of such a body to address the growing concerns of men falsely accused in legal matters.
A Men’s Commission could:
- Provide legal assistance to men facing false allegations.
- Investigate cases of misuse of laws and ensure fair trials.
- Offer counseling and mental health support for men struggling with legal harassment.
- Advocate for gender-neutral laws to ensure fairness in the justice system.
The Need for Laws to Protect Men
While India has strong laws for protecting women, there are no specific laws to safeguard men from false accusations, domestic abuse, or legal harassment. Many developed countries have gender-neutral laws, ensuring that both men and women receive fair treatment under the legal system. India must also consider:
- Punishment for false cases: Strict action should be taken against individuals who misuse laws to file false cases.
- Gender-neutral domestic violence laws: Domestic violence laws should be inclusive of male victims.
- Legal protection for men in marriages: Laws should ensure that both partners are treated fairly in marital disputes.
Conclusion
For a progressive society, it is essential to ensure justice for all, regardless of gender. Laws should be fair and unbiased, preventing misuse while protecting those who truly need support. The formation of a Men’s Commission and gender-neutral laws is not about denying women's rights but about ensuring that men are not wrongfully punished due to loopholes in the system.
If India truly seeks justice, it must acknowledge the challenges men face and take steps to protect them from legal exploitation. Only then can we create a society that is inclusive and just for everyone.
Back to Blogs